EP281 – BROWN LADY OF RAYNHAM HALL & MARY JANE FONDER

bROWN LADY OF RAYNHAM HALL STORY:

The legend of the Brown Lady dates back to the early 19th century. It is said that Lady Dorothy Walpole, the sister of the first Prime Minister of Great Britain, Robert Walpole, haunts the hallways of Raynham Hall. According to the tales, Lady Dorothy was locked away by her husband, Charles Townshend. She met a tragic end, whether by falling down the stairs or through suicide, is a matter of debate. 

The Brown Lady has been sighted by numerous witnesses, some even renowned skeptics who were compelled to question their beliefs in the face of this eerie entity. One of the most famous encounters occurred in 1835, when Colonel Loftus and Mr. Hawkins witnessed the apparition on the main staircase. So vivid was the encounter that Colonel Loftus even managed to sketch what he saw, and others agreed they had witnessed her too, but they didn’t know she was not a real lady.  

The biggest piece of evidence came when two photographers were shooting a spread for Country Life Magazine and ended up snapping a picture of the Brown Lady of Raynham Hall on the stairs.  Many people have said that the photo was doctored, but no one has been able to completely debunk the photo.  Even Harry Price himself believed the photographers when he interviewed them. 

While the Brown Lady remains the most famous apparition at Raynham Hall, she is not alone in haunting the premises. Over the years, reports of other strange occurrences have emerged, including sightings of a ghostly dog, two ghostly children, and even the Duke of Monmouth. These additional spirits only add to the mystique and haunted reputation of Raynham Hall.

The tragic tale of Lady Dorothy’s demise and her subsequent haunting has become deeply ingrained in the folklore of Raynham Hall. Speculations about the reasons for her ghostly manifestations range from her unhappy marriage to her illicit affair with Philip Wharton, a renowned politician who founded the Hellfire Club. Yet, despite the countless theories and chilling encounters, the true origins and motives behind the Brown Lady’s ghostly presence remain a mystery to this day.

mARY JANE FONDER STORY:

On January 23, 2008, the Trinity Evangelical Lutheran Church in Bucks County, Pennsylvania, became the backdrop for a chilling incident. Rhonda Smith, a temporary church secretary, was found brutally murdered inside the church premises. Initially, authorities considered suicide, but the evidence pointed in a different direction.

During their investigation, the police discovered the intriguing character of Mary Jane Fonder. A woman with a troubled past who had a run-in with the law in the past, having threatened someone with a gun. As the pieces started to fall into place, Fonder was arrested and subsequently found guilty of the crime.

Yet, the story does not end there. Mary Jane maintained her innocence and presented an alibi, stating that she was at a hairdresser’s appointment at the time of the murder. The police even checked a wig left at the salon for potential evidence but found nothing substantial. The police read the letters of condolence that Mary Jane wrote to the church and Rhonda’s parents, and that just added to the intrigue, because they were very self-centered and had a manipulative tone.

The turning point came when law enforcement uncovered a loaded gun in the lake. This weapon matched the bullets that had taken Rhonda Smith’s life. Ultimately, it was revealed that the gun belonged to none other than Mary Jane Fonder, solidifying the case against her. Her arrest and subsequent life sentence left many questions unanswered.

Piecing together Mary Jane’s behavior leading up to the crime revealed a disturbing pattern. The extent of her obsession with Pastor Greg Shreaves, combined with her feelings of jealousy and resentment towards other church members, painted a chilling picture. Mary Jane Fonder’s advances towards the pastor, coupled with her unrelenting attempts to involve the church in her personal and financial matters, showcased a disturbed mind seeking validation and control.

The story of Mary Jane Fonder serves as a stark reminder of the darkness that can lie within seemingly ordinary individuals. As we grapple with the unsettling details of this case, let us not forget the importance of addressing mental health issues in our society and working towards a future where tragedies like this can be prevented.

SPONSORS

This episode is sponsored by Care/of! Go to www.takecareof.com and use code CREEP50 for 50% off your first order!

This episode is also sponsored by Babbel!  If you want to start learning a new language, go to babbel.com/creep for up to 55% off your subscription!

×